Friday, 21 March 2014

Searching for Grey Parrots in Ghana

Posted by Nathaniel Annorbah & Stuart Marsden


In his study, Nat has to cover a huge study area of
60,000 sq. km across the South West of the country.

The aim of the PhD research is to assess the historic and current distribution, abundance and ecology of the Grey Parrot Psittacus erithacus in Ghana in order to make informed predictions about the sustainability of trade and land-use changes. Relevant data on other frugivorous birds such as hornbills and pigeons are being collected at the same time. Despite its large geographical distribution, the Grey Parrot population is suspected to be suffering a rapid decline because the extent of the annual harvest for international trade, and the high rate of ongoing habitat loss. The species is listed as Vulnerable in the (BirdLife International 2014).

Nat has already conducted surveys for Grey Parrots and other fruit-eating birds between April 2012 and March 2013, and he is now again in Ghana to continue his work on greys. His study area is huge - about 60,000 sq. km, comprising a mosaic of inhabited, cultivated and forested areas in south-western Ghana, the stronghold of grey parrots in the country.


Selective logging in forest reserves takes the largest trees. Logging company staff tell us that the huge trees they harvest often have 'nail ladders' allowing trappers to climb to the parrot nests (Photo: Stuart Marsden).



The study area was partitioned into a grid of 10 x 10 sq. km cells. A random sample of around 50 cells has been selected for surveys. 3-5 days are spent in each cell trying to find evidence for the presence of parrots and other frugivores. These ‘presence’ points will form the basis of a MAXENT analysis of current parrot distribution. Interviews were also conducted in the cells to obtain information about local people’s knowledge of the Grey Parrot, but also to record the socio-economic aspects of the its trade. Particularly important is the information on the historic presence of grey parrots in each cell – these points will form the ‘historic’ presence points for a MAXENT analysis of the past distribution.


Nat interviews local hunter-farmers to better understand the historic range of the Grey Parrot in SW Ghana (Photo: Stuart Marsden)

A great part of fieldwork was to locate roosts of Grey Parrots and to count birds to estimate roost population sizes. G. Dändliker (1992), a CITES consultant, did a survey of parrot roosts in Ghana in the early 1990s – some of these roosts contained hundreds of birds. It is our aim to visit as many of these roosts as possible to see how they have changed over in the subsequent 20 years. Locating roosts needs accurate information provided by trappers or local knowledge in general and a lot of legwork.

Fieldwork conditions: rain can soon transform roads in rivers (Photo: Nat Annorbah).




Fieldwork in Ghana has not been easy. Torrential rain makes ‘road’ conditions atrocious, the 4WD has taken a battering, electricity is scarce, and illnesses such as malaria are a real concern. Even local elections made things difficult in places.




A total of just 101 parrots were encountered during the first year’s survey. Parrots were recorded in just nine of the 31 surveyed sites surveyed  and not one wild grey parrot has so far been recorded in this year’s survey. Grey Parrots were present in only three of twelve roost sites revisited from the 1992 study and all 16 of Dändliker’s roosts visited so far this year have been ‘empty’. We will soon post on what looks like a collapse of the grey parrot population right across the country.


Excessive parrot trade has surely had a big hand in the disappearance of Grey Parrots from Ghana. Despite being incredibly rare in the wild, a few can still be found for sale.

References

BirdLife International. 2014. Species factsheet: Psittacus erithacus. Downloaded from http://www.birdlife.org on 14/02/2014.

Dändliker, G. 1992. The Grey Parrot in Ghana: a population survey, a contribution to the biology of the species, a study of its commercial exploitation and management recommendations. A report on CITES Project S-30.  Unpublished report to CITES.


Nat's PhD is funded by





Monday, 10 March 2014

Our Conservation, Evolution and Behaviour (CEB) Research Group launched

Posted by Stuart Marsden

Our new research group based in the School of Science & the Environment at Manchester Metropolitan University has just been launched (see http://www.staff.mmu.ac.uk/manmetlife/news/view/protecting-nature-around-the-world). With it comes what we hope will be an attractive and informative website introducing staff and their research interests, research students and their projects, news and activities, and links to teaching.  The CEB group website is in progress at http://www.ceerec.mmu.ac.uk/ceb/. It is worth a look, if only for the lovely photos.

 
(Photos. Top: Michele Menegon; Mid: Stuart Marsden; Bottom: Paul Donald)


The CEB group

Much of the conservation research we do focuses on biodiverse regions of the world. We are active across Africa, Southeast Asia and South America, working on birds, mammals, amphibians and other groups in tropical forests and other ecosystems. We also work closer to home, in British habitats on habitat fragmentation, restoration of salt marshes, impact of wind farms and noise pollution. We have a special interest in capacity building in developing countries both through PhD training, and taught MScs.


(Photos. Top: Paul Higginbottom; Mid and Bottom: Stuart Marsden)

An understanding of ecology, evolution and behaviour provides important insights and new perspectives on the science of conservation. Our group is interested in a wide variety of evolutionary and behavioural topics that range from bioacoustics and determinants of primate social structure to whale behaviour and bumble bee foraging. We also use theoretical models (such as random forest analyses) to assess extinction risks, and DNA sequence analyses to monitor gene flow and minimal viable population size. Our research ranges from the applied (GPS collar tracking of working Police dogs) to the more fundamental (behavioural neuroscience of rodent whiskers).


(Photos. Top: Michele Menegon; Mid: Christian Devenish; Bottom: Paul Donald)
There are around 15 permanent staff in the group. Information about the research interests of individual members of staff can be found within their staff webpages at http://www.ceerec.mmu.ac.uk/ceb/staff-profiles/. As is stressed in the MMU news piece, we see the group as more than just research. We all teach and supervise Masters students, and see the group as a focal point for our wider activities. For example, we have a thriving taught master’s programme with courses in Animal Behaviour, Conservation Biology, Countryside Management, Biological Recording, Conservation Genetics and Bird Conservation.


(Photos. Top: Michele Menegon; Mid: Stuart Marsden; Bottom: Paul Donald)

Saturday, 1 March 2014

Eyeing up the age structure of grey parrot populations

Posted by Filippo Marolla and Simon Valle

Filippo Marolla is a biology student from the Sapienza University of Rome. He's working with Simon to test some new methods for estimating densities and age ratio of Grey Parrots in Príncipe.

Among the several objectives we have set for our second fieldwork season in Príncipe, is a test of a non-invasive method for the estimation of the age ratio of the population of Grey Parrots. Determining the proportions of age classes in an animal population is crucial to the understanding of its dynamics and viability. However, this operation can be complicated for species which are hard to age in the field. To date, the only reliable method available to age Grey Parrots is the colour of the iris (Dändliker 1992). 



Downy chick with completely black iris (photo Filippo Marolla)



Captive fully fledged 'grey-eyed' juvenile grey parrot
 on Príncipe (Photo: Filippo Marolla)



When the chicks first open their eyes (about 7-10 days after hatching), the iris is black. During the first year, it slowly turns paler, passing through different shades of grey, and after the first year, it gradually turns bright yellow. Dändliker (1992) reckons that individuals can be aged up to four years of age, but, due to the variability among individuals, the only reliable separation is between first-year birds and others. Using this aging criterion can be quite easy for birds in captivity, but it can be a real nightmare in the wild, as parrots are either very difficult to approach when perched, or they typically fly high and fast in closed canopy forest.









Our objective is to test if photographs especially taken from strategic lookouts can be used as a method of estimating juvenile/non-juvenile ratio in Príncipe. We will take high-definition pictures of as many parrot individuals as we can, whether they are flying or foraging, using a Canon Eos 700D camera with a Zoom Lens EF 100-400mm (f/4.5-5.6). We are currently carrying out a training period in order to identify logistic problems and to improve our skills in taking good photos as quickly as needed. So far results are encouraging and, despite many ups and downs, the number of usable photos (i.e. where the iris colour is clearly recognizable) increases from session to session.


Three parrots flying over São Joaquim are readily identifiable as adults 
(Photo: Filippo Marolla)

Parrots often use preferential flyways to move daily in small flocks from foraging areas to roosting sites. We are focusing our efforts on some open areas located along these flight paths. Oque Daniel and El Miradouro are two elevated lookout points, located respectively in the North-West and in the East side of Príncipe, from where it's easy to spot parrots flying over, often right above your head. Other observation points, e.g. the surroundings of São Joaquim, are located in feeding sites such as flat areas with high densities of oil palms Elaeis guineensis, which give us the chance of taking pictures of perched birds. A typical working session consists in two hours of photo-catching during the time of the day in which parrots are most active, i.e. between 6 and 8 AM or between 4 PM and the sunset at 6 PM. 


View from El Miradouro, one of the strategic lookouts from which photos of flying grey parrots are taken in Príncipe (Photo: Simon Valle)

After some weeks of work, we are now able to provide some figures about how things are going.  In the best session in El Miradouro, we photo-catched 71 flying individual parrots on about 150 sighted, among which 25 have clearly recognizable iris colour, i.e. an aging success rate of 17.5%.


A grey parrot flying over shows the bright yellow eye typical of an adult
 (Photo: Filippo Marolla)

In the best session in São Joaquim, we photo-caught 22 perched individual parrots on about 43 sighted, with 10 individuals with clearly recognizable iris colour, i.e. an ageing success rate of 23%. Considering the practical difficulties associated with the method, we can be satisfied with the ageing rate we reached so far. 


 A perched adult feasting on the pollen from on Erythrina variegata  flowers 
 (Photo: Filippo Marolla) 


The first results are encouraging, suggesting that this kind of ‘photo-trapping’ might be useful for the study of grey parrot populations elsewhere in their vast range. Our next step is to see if we can detect changes in population structure across months using repeat photographic surveys. We expect the juvenile/non juvenile ratio to be at its maximum in March-April – when juveniles have just fledged – and at its minimum in August-September – when juvenile mortality has taken its toll. 


Two adults flying in a oil palm plantation in São Joaquim (Photo: Filippo Marolla)


This distant bird flying away is still readily identifiable as an adult 
(Photo: Stuart Marsden)


References

Dändliker, G. (1992). The Grey Parrot in Ghana: A population survey, a contribution to the biology of the species, a study of its commercial exploitation and management recommendations. A report on CITES Project S-30. Unpublished report to CITES.


The research on the Grey Parrots in Príncipe is funded by 



and supported by


















Wednesday, 19 February 2014

Managing domestic gardens collectively to promote urban biodiversity

Posted by Lee Dixon

Lee was a Research Masters student in our group before moving to University of Manchester to take up a ‘President Doctoral Scholarship’ to study urban biodiversity. Here he talks about his PhD work. 

Urban biodiversity


Cities frequently consist of a highly diverse mosaic of habitats which are subject to varying degrees of human intervention and manipulation. These habitats range from semi-natural habitats such as urban parks to totally artificial habitats such as industrial parks. As a result, cities have the capacity to hold a large number of ecological niches which in turn can support a surprising number of species. This biodiversity is vital for the sustained provision of ecosystem services, most notably those provided by pollination, but is also important for the health benefits that contact with nature has for humans.


Gardens are important habitat for Bumblebees (Bombus spp) currently declining in Europe and elsewhere as a result of urbanisation and climate change (Photo: Aconcagua).

To maintain high urban biodiversity and associated ecosystem service and health provision, it is important that growth in the world’s cities, land use changes, habitat fragmentation, and other by-products of human living such as pollution, do not result in loss of important species or communities. A key resource for urban wildlife is the domestic garden and their value is at the heart of my PhD. Urban gardens, although individually small in size, cover considerable areas of cities and have the capacity to hold a high level of biodiversity. As a result, domestic gardens taken as a collective entity may reasonably be described as a major nature reserve within cities. However, their value is contingent on the decisions made by householders about the composition of their own garden. 


Greater than 25% of the UK's national population of the Red Listed Song Thrush (Turdus philomelos) are held in domestic gardens (Photo: Tony Mills).

The habitat garden approach

The collective management of domestic gardens whereby multiple domestic gardens are managed in aggregation as a single habitat as opposed to individually (the habitat garden approach) has recently been proposed as a promising means to maintain or boost urban biodiversity. The approach is based on the 'species-area relationship', which describes the typical increase in number of species contained in larger and larger areas.It stands to reason that a collection of gardens all managed sympathetically for wildlife, as a single unit, may be better than individual gardens acting ‘unilaterally’.


South Manchester gardens make up a significant proportion of the urban landscape. Here is Stu's garden and the not-quite-as-nice gardens of his neighbours (Image: Google Maps).
There are, of course, social scientific factors which may influence the level of biodiversity within domestic gardens which are managed collectively as a single habitat. These include differences in how householders perceive the purposes of domestic gardens and different forms of garden wildlife, and the different garden management practices which they may implement in their gardens. These perceptions and management practices, if unfavourable to urban biodiversity, may nullify the potential benefits that this approach may bring to urban biodiversity and, as such, may form a constraining factor in its implementation in residential areas of cities. Moreover, it is unclear how institutions may promote householder perceptions and garden management practices which are favourable to urban biodiversity in order to maximise the potential benefits that the collective management of domestic gardens may bring for urban biodiversity.


'Privatisation' of domestic gardens such as the erection of fences and walls keep gardens relatively small in size and act as barriers to species' movement - in turn reducing the potential benefits that the habitat garden approach may bring to urban biodiversity (Photo: Lee Dixon).


The PhD


This research will explore what effect these householder perceptions and garden management practices may have on the potential benefits that the collective management of domestic gardens may bring for urban biodiversity and, with this taken into consideration, the feasibility of its implementation in cities. The research will also explore what incentives and approaches institutions could employ to promote householder perceptions and garden management practices which are favourable to urban biodiversity, and how these institutions may facilitate householder collaboration in the collective management of domestic gardens.


The specific objectives are


1.    To explore how householders perceive the purposes of domestic gardens, and garden wildlife

2.    To analyse how householder garden management practices may affect the biodiversity of domestic gardens

3.    To explore what incentives and approaches institutions could employ to promote biodiversity favourable householder perceptions and garden management practices

4.    To investigate if the collective management of domestic gardens is an appropriate approach to promoting urban biodiversity


Monday, 10 February 2014

Can hyenas help save mainland Africa’s most imperiled bird?

Posted by Bruktawit Muhamued, Huw Lloyd & Stuart Marsden

Once famed for its highly productive breed of Boran cattle, the Liben Plains of southern Ethiopia are in deep trouble – they are seriously overgrazed by cattle, being encroached by aggressive scrub species, and lost due to conversion to cereal crops. These changes have grave consequences for the livelihoods of the local pastoralists and at the same time have pushed the endemic Liben Lark Heteromirafra archeri to the brink of extinction. The Lark may now represent mainland Africa’s most threatened bird species. 

Liben Lark Heteromirafra archeri. Photo: Paul Donald

The conservation of the Liben Plain rangelands and its fauna requires designing an appropriate habitat restoration strategy that incorporates the traditional Gadda system of grassland management, whilst also mitigating possible adverse effects on rural livelihoods. MMU PhD student Bruktawit Muhamued has been working on the Liben Plain collecting ecological data on this ‘Critically endangered’ bird along with socio-economic information on local livelihoods and lifestyles. Working with Huw Lloyd and Stu at MMU, along with Nigel Collar (BirdLife International), Paul Donald (RSPB), and rangeland ecologist James Bennett (Coventry University), Bruk is creating an important evidence base to find compromises good for both people and the lark. 


The Liben Plains with Boran cattle. Photo: Paul Donald

Since June 2013, we have been collecting data on the abundance, foraging behaviour, and habitat associations of the lark. These data will enable Bruktawit to estimate the Lark’s global population size, to determine whether it is restricted to areas of traditional Gadda managed grassland habitat and how the species responds to shifting land use practices brought about by changes to the economic realities faced by native pastoralists.

Bruk prepares artificial lark nests. Photo: Huw Lloyd
Perhaps the best hope for lark’s survival has come from an unlikely source. A few years ago we found small patches of longer grass on the overgrazed plain – areas where the cows seemed not to want to feed. Even stranger was that these areas were dotted with white hyena dungs – and it was this pooh that the cows were avoiding. We wondered whether we might be able to use hyena excrement to create small patches of nesting habitat in an otherwise overgrazed landscape. The scats would act as a biological control to reduce overgrazing – just as people use wolf urine or tiger faeces to deter deer and other ‘pests’ from entering gardens and fields.



Bruk is using artificial nest experimental plots demarcated with hyena dung, which will enable her to monitor the natural restoration of grassland vegetation, and determine the survival rates of the artificial nests. Hyena dung collection has been one of the most challenging aspects of her first fieldwork season! 
Spotted Hyena and the 'white gold' that is its dung. 
Photos: Bruk
Hyenas regularly come into contact with rural and small urban populations in Ethiopia, feeding in close proximity to rural houses and rubbish dumps. The challenge is to collect not only enough pooh but also dung of the right quality! There are several locations in the region where this is possible, although sometimes, the local hyenas can become a little puzzled or inquisitive at the unusual interest in their waste products!




Bruk's PhD is supported by Manchester Metropolitan University along with A.G. Leventis Foundation, RSPB and BirdLife International.

  

Saturday, 1 February 2014

Dishing the dirt on Peru’s parrots

Posted by Alan Lee and Stuart Marsden

Alan Lee finished his PhD in the group three years ago. His PhD, supervised by Stu, along with Martin Jones (MMU), and Donald Brightsmith of Texas A&M University, focused on the ecology of the rich parrot community of southeastern Peru, and in particular examined how and why the various species consume clay at colpas (claylicks). Geophagy is the intentional consumption of ‘dirt’ – something which a surprising variety of animals do. Chimpanzees and a range of new world monkeys have been recorded eating dirt (often from termitaria). Herbivorous mammals such as tapir, peccary, deer, agoutis and bats have been recorded drinking salty water and eating dirt at claylicks in South America, while several publications have examined geophagy in elephants in Africa and Asia. Markets in West Africa sell small bags of special clay for pregnant women. 


Red-and-green Macaws at the Blanquillo claylick in Manu

Geophagy and consumption of mineral-rich water is common in the tropics especially among frugivorous birds such as parrots and pigeons. This said, we still do not know how common and widespread geophagy is in birds – largely because it is difficult to observe in the vast and little-known tropical forests. Previous work by Dr Craig Symes, another South African who worked in our group, recorded fourteen pigeon species and six parrot species practising geophagy, or drinking salt water in a forest in Papua New Guinea (61% of the sites parrots and 30% of parrots). Cassowary was recorded eating blue soil rich in iron and the conclusion from this study is that different birds in the area were using different dirt for different reasons (Symes et al. 2006).

Alan and Red-tailed Boa Constrictor




Before his PhD, Alan had spent a couple of years working for an NGO ostensibly to investigate the impacts of tourism on Amazonian wildlife, and volunteered on the Tambopata Macaw Project under Donald Brightsmith. He learnt a lot about the wildlife of the region but was most fascinated by the geophagy sites along the rivers of SE Peru, where parrots would flock together in the early morning, fly around noisily, look spectacularly beautiful and then some of them would descend to the river banks to munch on soil. But not always, and not evenly, and not everywhere. It was Alan’s task to figure out if there was a pattern to this spectacle – a spectacle so impressive that several successful tourist enterprises had been built on the back of this raucous feathered firework show. 

 








Together with a handful of volunteers from all walks of life, we spent hundreds of hours at many parrot geophagy sites across the Peruvian Amazon. We braved jaguars, herds of peccary, floods, rabid bats, terrorist attacks, flesh eating diseases, and a host of other difficulties to try and understand parrots and their ways. The first job was to map out across the entire continent where the claylicks were found, and to use MaxEnt, a presence-only species (or in this case, claylick) distribution model to determine where claylicks were and perhaps why they were in some areas and not others. We realised that they were only found in the western sections of the Amazon, where sodium deficits are the greatest (Lee et al. 2010).



The next job was to put the numbers of parrots which regularly use the region’s riverbank claylicks into perspective of the numbers of parrots in the areas – do all parrots visit claylicks everyday? We made many counts of parrots at various claylicks but a more difficult job was trying to survey parrots in the tall and complex Amazonian forest. This problem led us to propose a variant of Distance Sampling based on call counts which may be a useful line transect method in tall forests (Lee & Marsden 2012). In respect to geophagy, our results suggested that only a small proportion of the parrots in the area visit claylicks on a given day – the consumption of clay seems to be more of a ‘topping up’ habit than a daily necessity.



This is important in terms of our understanding of why parrots eat dirt. While several researchers have posited that the soil was being consumed for the sodium contained therein, a PhD conducted by Jamie Gilardi during the nineties had convinced much of the world that the soil was consumed in order to neutralise the natural toxins found in the seeds and unripe fruit. This is a fascinating possibility – Jared Diamond and team in a publication on geophagy and birds from Papua New Guinea highlighted the behaviour in the light of the toxin-arms race between plants and parrots who predate rather than disperse their seeds (Diamond et al. 1999). 

Dusky-headed Parakeets and Blue-headed Macaws

That claylicks are concentrated in a small portion of South America where sodium deficits are likely to be highest, and that parrots tend to visit claylicks periodically and not continuously may suggest that the reason for parrot geophagy is mineral- rather than toxin-related. A final strand of enquiry, which we are about to publish, looked at the diets of different parrot species and their tendency to visit claylicks. Again, we were unable to link geophagy to toxin neutralization - in fact, it was flower-eating successional-forest parrot species that seemed to consume more soil than those large macaws that predate more toxin-rich seeds and unripe fruit. We will detail these findings in an upcoming post.


Alan now has a postdoctoral research position at the University of Cape Town investigating how the endemic birds of South Africa's endemic biome (the Fynbos) will fare under climate change scenarios. The work is almost as exciting as it was in the Amazon – you can read all about it at http://bluehillescape.blogspot.com/

Alan's PhD research was done in association with the Tambopata Macaw Project

 macaw logo


References


Diamond, J., Bishop, K.D. & Gilardi, J.D. (1999). Geophagy in New Guinea birds. Ibis 141: 181-193.


Lee, A.T., Kumar, S., Brightsmith, D. & Marsden, S.J. (2010) Distribution of claylicks and their use by parrots across South America: Do patterns of where help answer the question why? Ecography 33: 503-513.


Lee, A.K.T. & Marden, S.J. (2012). The influence of habitat, season and detectability on abundance estimates across an Amazonian parrot assemblage. Biotropica 44: 537-544.


Symes, C. T., Hughes, J. C., Mack, A. L. & Marsden, S. J. (2006). Avian geophagy in the Crater Mountain Wildlife Management Area, Papua New Guinea. Journal of Zoology 268: 87-96.